For three years, my neighbor barely left her house and lived behind closed doors with a child no one had ever seen. The moment I caught a glimpse through her window, I realized why, and my heart stopped cold.
Something always felt off about my neighbor Nelly. In three years, I’d barely seen her outside, except to check the mail or drive to the store. What felt even stranger was that she’d been heavily pregnant when she moved in. Yet, no one had seen her baby even once in these three years.
I shook my head, trying to dispel the uneasy feeling. “Get it together, Martha,” I muttered to myself, gripping the edge of the sink.
Later that evening, I sat on the porch with my husband, Evan, watching our boys kick a soccer ball around the yard. The setting sun painted the sky in hues of orange and pink, but I couldn’t shake the shadow of unease.
“Evan,” I began, hesitating. “Have you noticed anything odd about our neighbor?”
He raised an eyebrow, taking a sip of his beer. “Nelly? What about her?”
“It’s just she’s so isolated. I tried talking to her at the supermarket the other day, and she practically ran away.”
Evan chuckled, his arm draped casually over the back of the porch swing. “Some people just aren’t social butterflies, Martha. Not everyone’s cut out for neighborhood barbecues and block parties.”
“I suppose. But what about her baby? No one’s seen the child in three years. Isn’t that strange?”
He shrugged, his eyes following the boys’ game. “Maybe she’s just protective. Don’t worry so much, hon. Focus on our family.”
I forced a smile, but the nagging feeling persisted. “You’re right. I’m probably overthinking it.”
Evan leaned over, planting a kiss on my cheek. “That’s my girl. Now, how about we join the boys for a game?”
As we stepped off the porch, I cast one last glance at Nelly’s house. The curtains twitched, and for a moment, I could have sworn I saw a small face peering out. But when I blinked, it was gone.
A week later, I spotted Nelly in her garden, picking herbs. Seizing the opportunity, I approached the fence. “Beautiful day, isn’t it?” I called out cheerfully.
Nelly’s head snapped up, her eyes wide with fear. Before I could say another word, she bolted inside and slammed the door behind her.
“Well, that was rude.”
“Talking to yourself, Martha?” a voice chimed in. I turned to see my neighbor, Mrs. Freddie, peering over her fence. “What in the world was that about?”
“I have no idea. But something’s not right, Mrs. Freddie. I can feel it.”
“Leave it to me, dear. I’ll get to the bottom of this.”
“What are you planning?”
She winked. “You’ll see. Sometimes, a little Southern hospitality is all it takes to crack a tough nut.”
As Mrs. Freddie disappeared into her house, I couldn’t help but wonder if we were making a mountain out of a molehill.
But then again, in our picturesque neighborhood where friendly gatherings were the norm, Nelly’s behavior stood out like a sore thumb.
The next day, I found myself once again at the kitchen window, this time watching Mrs. Freddie march up to Nelly’s door. In her hands was a homemade apple pie.
“This ought to be interesting,” I murmured, leaning closer to the glass.
Mrs. Freddie knocked, waiting with a bright smile plastered on her face. The seconds ticked by, and I held my breath.
Finally, the door cracked open slightly. I strained to hear the conversation, but all I caught was Nelly’s sharp voice ringing out, “Go away!” followed by another resounding slam.
Mrs. Freddie hurried back, her face flushed with anger. I met her halfway across my lawn.
“Did you see that?” she exclaimed, handing over the rejected pie. “The nerve of that woman!”
“What is she hiding, Mrs. Freddie? This isn’t normal behavior.”
“I don’t know, dear, but mark my words… there’s something fishy going on in that house.”
As we stood there, speculating, I couldn’t shake the feeling that we were on the brink of uncovering something big. Something that would change our quiet suburban lives forever.
A few days later, I was sorting through the mail when I came across a letter addressed to Nelly. The mailman must have mixed up our boxes. I stared at the envelope, an idea forming.
“This is my chance,” I whispered, glancing around as if Nelly might suddenly appear.
I made my way to her house. As I approached the front door, a movement caught my eye. Curiosity got the better of me, and I peered through the window.
My heart stopped.
A little boy, no older than three, stared back at me. His eyes… they were so familiar. And on his cheek was a birthmark I knew all too well.
I let out a bloodcurdling scream, my legs giving way as I collapsed on the steps.
The last thing I saw before darkness claimed me was the little boy’s face.
“Martha! Martha, can you hear me?”
I blinked, faces swimming into focus above me. My neighbors crowded around, concern etched on their faces. Mrs. Freddie was dabbing my forehead with a damp cloth, her brow furrowed with worry.
“What happened?” she asked, helping me sit up.
The memory hit me like a freight train. I scrambled to my feet, ignoring their protests, and pounded on Nelly’s door.
“Nelly! It’s Martha. I know who the father of your child is! Open up!”
The neighborhood held its breath as the door slowly creaked open. Nelly stood there, pale and trembling, with the little boy peeking out from behind her legs.
Gasps echoed around me as everyone saw what I had seen — the birthmark on the child’s cheek, identical to my husband’s.
“How could you?” I choked out, tears streaming down my face.
Nelly’s shoulders sagged, defeat written in every line of her body. “I’m so sorry, Martha. I never meant for this to happen.”
The little boy tugged on Nelly’s skirt. “Mommy, who’s that lady?”
My heart shattered at his innocent question. “I’m your father’s wife,” I whispered.
We sat in Nelly’s living room. The little boy, Tommy, played quietly in the corner while Nelly sat across from me.
“Start from the beginning,” I demanded.
Nelly took a shaky breath, her hands twisting in her lap. “Four years ago, I met Evan at a bar. We hit it off. It was supposed to be a one-time thing, but then I found out I was pregnant.”
“And?”
“I told Evan. He panicked. Said he couldn’t lose his family. He offered to take care of me and the baby, but only if I agreed to keep it a secret.”
“By hiding away for three years?”
Nelly nodded, shame coloring her cheeks. “It was his idea to move me next door. He thought it would be easier to keep an eye on things. But I had to promise never to speak to anyone, especially you, and never bring Tommy outside.”
I looked at Tommy, his innocent face a painful reminder of Evan’s betrayal. “Does he know? About Evan being his father?”
Nelly shook her head. “No. Evan visits sometimes, but Tommy thinks he’s just a friend.”
The revelation hit me like a ton of bricks. All those business trips and late nights at the office. How long had this been going on right under my nose?
“What happens now?” I asked, more to myself than to Nelly.
She reached out, hesitating before placing a hand on my arm. “Whatever you decide, Martha. I’ll understand if you want us to leave.”
I stood up abruptly, needing to escape. “I need time to think.”
I ran home, a veil of tears clouding my eyes.
The week dragged by in a haze of tears and sleepless nights.
I went through the motions, caring for my boys while my heart shattered into a million pieces. Every time I looked at my sons Jake and Ethan, I saw the brother they didn’t know they had.
When Evan returned from his week-long business trip, I was waiting. I had spent days rehearsing this moment, steeling myself for the confrontation.
“Welcome home, honey,” I said.
Evan’s face lit up as he dropped his briefcase bag. “Hey, beautiful. Miss me?”
“Of course. I have a surprise for you.”
“Oh yeah? What is it?”
I gestured to an envelope on the table. “Open it.”
Evan tore into the envelope, his smile fading as he realized what he was holding. Divorce papers.
“Martha, what—”
I clapped my hands, cutting him off. On cue, Nelly emerged from the kitchen with Tommy in her arms.
Evan’s face drained of color. “Oh God! Martha, I can explain—”
“Save it. I know everything. We’re done, Evan.”
He stumbled back, looking frantically between me, Nelly, and Tommy. “Please, let me explain. It was a mistake.”
“A mistake? A mistake is forgetting to pick up milk. This? This is a betrayal. You lied to me for years, Evan. You have another child!”
Confused by the raised voices, Tommy began to cry. Nelly hushed him, shooting Evan a look of disgust.
The aftermath was a whirlwind. Horrified by their son’s actions, Evan’s parents gave me half of their company as compensation after the divorce.
I accepted, knowing it would secure my boys’ future.
As for Nelly and Tommy, they moved away shortly after. Part of me felt sorry for them. But a larger part was too busy trying to heal.
One afternoon, as I watched my sons playing in the backyard, a realization hit me. I may not be able to change the past, but I could shape the future.
I called the boys over, pulling them into a tight hug.
“Listen to me,” I said, looking into their innocent faces. “I want you to promise me something. Always be honest, kind, and respectful. Treat others the way you want to be treated. Can you do that for me?”
They nodded solemnly, and I felt a glimmer of hope. The road ahead would be tough, but I was determined to raise my boys to be better men than their father.